Originally Posted by Proud Marine Dad

Considering the ingredients as I see them I think they are full of crap to be quite blunt. As I said earlier, eliminating the chicken meal does NOT make the food drop from 5 stars to 3 stars.

In regards to how a dog does on certain foods I don't put much faith in that. I know people who feed their purebreds crap like 'Ol Roy or Purina One and their dogs live long lives. The food may not be harmful but I think they could certainly be fed something of higher value.
Us humans could eat Taco Bell, McDonald's, Wendy's and others all our lives as well and possibly live to an old age but I still do not think that is a quality of life that I would recommend for anyone!