Awhile back I posted that I was thinking about switching my one yr old from Before Grain to TOTW, because they were so similar in ingredients, but TOTW was about half the price. Well I made the switch. It took me about a month to fully switch her over, (I wanted the transition to take awhile) and from day one she loved TOTW. She acts as if I have never fed her before. As soon as I tell her its ok to start eating she digs right in and then looks at me, like hey can I have some more dad, this stuff is good. Glad I made the swith. She still looks about the same as far as muscle tone and body size although with it raining so much in Michigan she has lost some muscle because we arent outside for hrs on end. Just wanted to say that my wallet and my little girl is doing great after the switch.