what's your take on that she never has accidents while I'm watching her?Sounds like she has diarrhea a lot.. if she has an upset stomach that is not necessarily correlated with being house broken.
She might just be sick and physically unable to hold it.
But lets talk about the peeing. i think the key here is that you are going to have to put the effort in to only have her out of the cage when you are in the same room with her for like 6 weeks.
You said "I gotcha...although at this point - this argument is almost irrelevant because she never has accident when I can even punish her "
And this is where you need to put the effort in IMO, stop letting her off and pee away from you. Put up baby gates to block stuff or whatever you need to do.
Okay i finally have a dog again after 6 months. its a 8 week old puppy.so I started giving chicken treats and she's taking them outside
we're watching her very closely. Hopefully she will be potty trained by end of month