Well, my puppy Rocky... Sometimes it can take after 3 hours of eating until he poops. Another thing is that usually over night or early morning he makes really soft poop. It does have form but is very soft. I do take him out after eating but he doesn't seem to even want to go. Just kinda worried because it takes a while and I'm not sure if this is normal or what, and the fact that at times his poop can be really soft. If it helps, I feed him Solid Gold. 3 times a day with measurements according. 1 cup morning and night, half in the middle.